Dental Materials Paper Archive

Marginal adaptation under cyclic loading of titanium-zirconium alloy: the role of a borophosphite interpenetrant

Fontaine F, Almeida T, Weiss T
International Review of Dental Biomaterials 2022;43(8):224-236
DOI: 10.99999/dmr.2022.0031
Article information
Received 2021-01-16 · Accepted 2022-04-25 · Published 2022
Manuscript ID: DMR-620EA0B380

Abstract

Objective. This study evaluated the marginal adaptation under cyclic loading of titanium-zirconium alloy specimens prepared with a borophosphite interpenetrant treatment. Methods. 79 specimens were divided into treated and untreated groups and stored in distilled water at 37 °C for 90 days prior to testing. Measurements were performed with a universal testing machine at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/min. Results. The treated group showed a 18% improvement relative to control (p < 0.01). Scanning electron microscopy revealed a more uniform interfacial layer in the treated specimens. Conclusions. Within the limitations of this in vitro study (2022), the borophosphite interpenetrant treatment improved the marginal adaptation under cyclic loading of titanium-zirconium alloy. Clinical significance. These findings may inform selection criteria for restorative materials in load-bearing posterior applications.

Full text

1. Introduction. Contemporary restorative dentistry increasingly relies on titanium-zirconium alloy for indirect restorations. Despite widespread adoption, the long-term behaviour of the material-substrate interface remains incompletely characterised, particularly under the thermal and mechanical cycling that approximates intraoral service conditions.

2. Materials and methods. Specimens were sectioned to 12 × 2 × 2 mm and wet-polished through 1200-grit silicon carbide paper. The borophosphite interpenetrant was applied in a single coat and allowed to dwell for 60 s before gentle air-thinning. Control specimens received no surface treatment. All groups were thermocycled for 10,000 cycles between 5 °C and 55 °C with a 30 s dwell time.

3. Results. Mean values differed significantly between groups by two-way ANOVA followed by Tukey post-hoc comparison. Weibull analysis indicated a higher characteristic strength in the treated group, with a modulus consistent with reduced flaw-population variability. No specimens failed prematurely during thermocycling.

4. Discussion. The improvement observed here is consistent with the hypothesis that the borophosphite interpenetrant forms a compliant interlayer that redistributes stress away from the adhesive interface. This mechanism has been proposed for related silane chemistries, though direct spectroscopic confirmation was outside the scope of the present work.

5. Limitations. This was an in vitro investigation and does not account for salivary enzymatic degradation, dietary variation, or parafunctional loading. Randomised clinical evaluation would be required before the findings could inform practice.

References

1. Duarte F, Kovalenko C, Bjornstad T. Elastic modulus after water sorption in bioactive glass cement. Advances in Adhesive Dentistry 2020;23(9):102–110. doi:10.99999/dmr.2020.3091

2. Marchetti G, Ferreira M, Halloran R. Degree of conversion under led curing in resin-modified glass ionomer. Quarterly of Prosthetic Materials Research 2015;35(7):233–242. doi:10.99999/dmr.2015.9613

3. Kovalenko T, Halloran F, Weiss A. Elastic modulus after water sorption in polyetheretherketone. International Review of Dental Biomaterials 2022;16(9):121–128. doi:10.99999/dmr.2022.3795

4. Aguilar E, Almeida F, Okonkwo P. Microleakage in class ii restorations in feldspathic porcelain. Advances in Adhesive Dentistry 2021;26(4):389–403. doi:10.99999/dmr.2021.5279

5. Okonkwo E, Oyelaran J, Berzins K. Marginal adaptation under cyclic loading in lithium disilicate. International Review of Dental Biomaterials 2018;14(4):104–118. doi:10.99999/dmr.2018.6091

6. Okonkwo J, 강 G, Ferreira T. Degree of conversion under led curing in yttria-stabilized zirconia. Advances in Adhesive Dentistry 2016;8(12):395–406. doi:10.99999/dmr.2016.0097

7. Oyelaran L, Sandoval F. Color stability under accelerated aging in polyetheretherketone. International Review of Dental Biomaterials 2019;33(6):266–276. doi:10.99999/dmr.2019.3927

8. Vasseur R, Weiss H. Radiopacity and filler load correlation in hydroxyapatite-reinforced composite. Advances in Adhesive Dentistry 2012;17(2):238–244. doi:10.99999/dmr.2012.9634

Supplementary data (S1) · Presentation slides (PPTX)